Isaac Scientific Publishing

Journal of Advanced Statistics

Two Treatment Repeated Measurement Designs With Uncorrelated Observations: A Compact Review

Download PDF (306.7 KB) PP. 26 - 34 Pub. Date: March 1, 2017

DOI: 10.22606/jas.2017.21004


  • Miltiadis S. Chalikias*
    Piraeus University of Applied Science


Hedayat and Afsarinejad (1975,1978) introduced the model for repeated measurement designs without interactions which was the basis for the next researchers. We present the optimal designs for the direct and carry over effect of the model for 2,3, and 4 periods. Moreover, universally optimal designs, Φ optimal and balanced designs are also presented based on the conditions of Cheng and Wu (1980) and Chalikias and Kounias (2012).


Repeated Measurements designs, direct effects, carry-over effects, universally optimality


[1] Azzalini, A. and Giovagnoli, A. (1987). Some optimal designs for repeated measures with autoregressive errors. Biometrika, 74, 725–734.

[2] Balaan, L.N. (1965). A Two-Period Design for Treatment by Period Interaction. Paper No. BU-177-M, Biometrics unit, Kent University.

[3] Balaan, L. N.(1968). A two period design witht2 experimental units. Biometrics unit, Cornell University 24, 61-73.

[4] Bardzokas D., Lalou P. (2009) The method of Complex Analysis for the solution of plane problems of the theory of Thermoconductivity and Thermoelasticity for multiply connected bodies, Proceeding of National Academy of sciences of Armenia, Mechanics, No4. Vol 62, 23-41.

[5] Bardzokas D., Lalou P. (2007) The influence of coupled thermal fields on the behavior of cracked bodies, Proceedings of 4th National conference on NDM

[6] Bose, M.and Mukherjee, B(2000). Cross over designs in the presence of higher order carey overs. ANZ Journal of Statistics. 42(1): 235-244

[7] Candel, M.J.J.M. 2012 Parallel, AA/BB, AB/BA and Balaam's design: Efficient and maximin choices when testing the treatment effect in a mixed effects linear regression Pharmaceutical Statistics Volume 11, Issue 2, pages 97–106, March/April 2012.

[8] Carriere C., Huang R. (2000) Crossover designs for two treatment clinical trials. Journal of Statistical planning and inference. 87 (1): 125134.

[9] Carriere K. C. and Reinsel G. C. (1992). Investigation of dual-balanced crossover designs for two treatments. Biometrics 48, 1157-1164.

[10] Carriere K. C. and Reinsel G. C. (1993). Optimal two period repeated measurement designs with two or more treatments. Biometrika, 80, 4, 924-929.

[11] Chalikias M., and Kounias S.(2012). Extension and necessity of Cheng and Wu conditions Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference 142 (7) , pp. 1794-1800.

[12] Chalikias M., Kounias S., (2017). Optimal two Treatment Repeated Measurement Designs for three Periods Communications in Statistics – Theory and Methods Vol 46, Pages: 200-209

[13] Cheng, C.S. and Wu C.F. (1980 ). Balanced repeated measurements designs. Ann. Statist 11, 29-50. Correction (1983) 11, 349.

[14] Cochran, W.G., Autrey, K.M., and Cannon, C.Y. (1941). A double change-over design for dairy cattle feeding experiments. J. Dairy Sci., 24, 937-51.

[15] Diggle, P., & Kenward, M. G. (1994). Informative drop-out in longitudinal data analysis. Applied statistics, 49- 93.

[16] Fleis, J.L. (1989). A critique of recent research on the two-treatment crossover design Controlled Clinical Trials 10, 237-243.

[17] Freeman, P.R. (1989). The performance of the two-stage analysis of two-treatment, two-period crossover trials. Statistics in Medicine 8, 1421-1432.

[18] Hedayat, A. S.and Afsarinejad K.(1975). Repeated measurements designs I. A survey of Statistical Designs and Linear Models, J.N. Srivastava editor, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 229-242.

[19] Hedayat, A. S. and Afsarinejad K.(1978). Repeated measurements designs II. Ann. Statist. 18, 1805-1816.

[20] Hedayat, A. and Zhao W. (1990). Optimal two period repeated measurements designs. Ann. Statist. vol. 18, No. 4, 1805-1816.

[21] Hedayat, A. S. and Yang, M. (2003).Universal Optimality of Balanced Uniform Crossover Designs. Ann. Statist., 31, 978-983.

[22] Hedayat, A. S. and Yang, M. (2004).Universal Optimality of Selected Crossover Designs. J. Am. Statist. Assoc., vol. 99, No 466, 461-466.

[23] John, J.A., Quenuille, M.H. (1977). Experiments: Design and Analysis. Charles Griffin & Co. Ltd, London.

[24] Jones, B., & Kenward, M. G. (2014). Design and analysis of cross-over trials. CRC Press.

[25] Kiefer, J. (1975). Construction and optimality of generalized Youden squares. A survey of Statistical Design and Linear Models. J.N. Srivastava, Editor, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 333-353.

[26] Kershner, R.P. and Federer, W.T. (1981). Two-treatment Crossover Design for Estimating a variety of Effects. J. Am. Statist. Assoc., vol 76, 612-619.

[27] Kiefer, J., & Wolfowitz, J. (1960). The equivalence of two extremum problems. Canadian Journal of Mathematics, 12(5), 363-365.

[28] Kounias, S & Chalikias, M (2008a). Optimal and universally optimal two treatment repeated measurement designs. F. Vonta et al., editors, Statistics for industry and technology Birkhauser, Boston, Basel, Berlin, 465-477.

[29] Κounias, S., Chalikias M., (2008b), Estimability of parameters in a linear model and related characterisations, Statistics and Probability Letters 78 (15):2437-2439

[30] Kounias, S., & Chalikias M.S.,(2015) “Optimal two treatment repeated measurement designs with treatmentperiod interaction in the model” Utilitas Mathematica, 96, 243-261.

[31] Kunert, J. (1983). Optimal design and refinement of the linear model with applications to repeated measurements designs. Ann. Statist., 11, 247-257.

[32] Kunert, J. (1984a). Optimality of balanced uniform repeated measurements designs. Ann. Statist., 12, 1006-1017.

[33] Kunert, J. (1984b). Optimal repeated measurements designs for correlated observations and analysis by weighted least squares. Biometrika 72, 375-389.

[34] Kunert, J. (1991). Cross-over designs for two treatments and correlated errors. Biometrika 78, 315-324.

[35] Kunert I and Stufcken, J (2000). Optimal cross over designs in a model with self and mixed carry over effects. Journal of the American Statistical Association 459 (97): 898-906.

[36] Kushner, H.B. (1997a). Optimality and Efficiency of the Two Treatment Repeated Measurements Design. Biometrika, 84, 455-468.

[37] Kushner, H.B. (1997b). Optimal Repeated Measurements Designs: The Linear Optimality Equations.. Ann. Statist., 25, 2328-2344.

[38] Kushner, H.B. (1998). Optimal and Efficient Repeated- Measurements Designs for Uncorrelated observations. J. Am. Statist. Assoc, Vol. 93, 443, 1176-1187.

[39] Kushner, H.B. (1999). H-symmetric optimal repeated measurements designs Journal of statistical planning and inference, Vol. 76, issues1-2 pages 235-261.

[40] Lalou P., (2012) Integral equations of the problem thermoelasticity in cracked isotropic plate with inclusion, Applied Mathematical Sciences, Vol 6, No 62, 3081-3093.

[41] Laska, E.M., Meisner M. and Kushner H.B. (1983). Optimal crossover designs in the presence of carryover effects. Biometrics 39, 1087-1091.

[42] Laska, E.M. and Meisner M. (1985). A variational approach to optimal two treatment cross-over designs: application to carryover effect models. J. Am. Statist. Assoc. 80, 704-710.

[43] Lawes, J.B. and Gilbert, J.H. (1864). Report of experiments on the growth of wheat for twenty years in succession on the same land. Journal of theAgricultural Society of England, 25, 93-185, 449-501.

[44] Liang, Y. and Carriere, K. C. (2010), On the Role of Baseline Measurements for Crossover Designs under the Self and Mixed Carryover Effects Model. Biometrics, 66: 140–148.

[45] Liebing, J. (1847). Chemistry in its Application to Agriculture and Physiology , 4th edition, Taylor and Walton, London.

[46] Longford N. (1993). Random effects models. Oxford Science Publications.

[47] Lucas, E.L. (1957). Extra-Period Latin-Square Change over design. Journal of Dairy Science, 40, 225-239.

[48] Magda, C.G. (1980). Circular balanced repeated measurements designs. Commun. Statist.-Theor. Meth. A9, 1901-1918.

[49] Mathews, J.N.S. (1987). Optimal crossover designs for the comparison of two treatments in the presence of carryover effects and autocorrelated errors. Biometrika, 74, 2, 311-320.

[50] Mathews, J.N.S. (1990). Optimal dual-balanced two treatment crossover designs. Sankhya, 52, B, 3, 332-337.

[51] Mathews, J.N.S. (1994). Modeling and optimality in the design of crossover studies for medical applications. Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference, 42, 89-108.

[52] Patterson, H. D. and Lucas, H. L.(1959). Extra period change-over designs. Biometrics, 15, 116-132.

[53] Patterson, H. D. and Lucas, H. L.(1962). Change-over designs. North Carolina Agricultural Experimental Station, Tech. Bull. No 147.

[54] Ratkowsky, D.A., Evans, M.A., Alldredge, J.R. (1999). Cross-Over Experiments. Marcel Dekker, Inc.

[55] Reed J.F(2004)Analysis of two-treatment, two-period crossover trials in emergency medicine Annals of Emergency Medicine Volume 43, Issue 1, January, Pages 54–58

[56] Queuneille h. (1953) The design analysis of experiments. London: Charles Griffin and Company Ltd

[57] Simpson., T.W. (1938). Experimental methods and human nutrition (with discussion). Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B, 5, 46-69.

[58] Shah, K.R. and Sinha, B.K. (1989). Theory of Optimal Designs. Lecture Notes in Statistics. Springer, New York.

[59] Sinha, B.K. (1975). On some optimum properties of serially balanced designs. Sankhya Ser. B, 37, 173-192.

[60] Silvey, S. D., & Titterington, D. M. (1973). A geometric approach to optimal design theory. Biometrika, 60(1), 21-32.

[61] Stufken, J.(1991). Some families of optimal and efficient repeated measurements designs. Journal of Statistical Planning and Inference, 27, 75-83.

[62] Stufken, J.(1996). Optimal crossover designs. Design and Analysis of Experiments. Handbook of Statistics 13, (S. Ghosh and C.R.Rao, eds.), 63-90, North-Holland, Amsterdam.

[63] Williams, E.J.(1949). Experimental designs balanced for the estimation of residual effects of treatments. Aust. J. Sci. Res., A, 2, 149-168.

[64] Williams, E.J.(1950). Experimental designs balanced for pairs of residual effects. Aust. J. Sci. Res., A, 3, 351- 363.

[65] Williams, E.R. and John, J.A. (2007), Construction of crossover designs with correlated errors Australian & New Zealand Journal of Statistics, 49: 61–68.

[66] Wynn, H. P. (1977). Minimax purposive survey sampling design. Journal of the American Statistical Association, 72(359), 655-657.